hd-dvd and blu-ray: no choices

I’ve started seeing these commercials on TV talking about next-generation DVDs and the formats they use, and one of the two (I think it’s Blu-Ray) says something like, “Make the right choice, go with Blu-Ray!” The fact of the matter is this, though – there are no choices. In fact, the only one you have is whether you want the film or not.I’m not sure if studios are deluded into thinking this or not, but the reality is that consumers do not normally weigh the studio that something comes from when it comes to the “how good is it” karma. Hobbyists do, but that’s it. And there is one exception to the rule — the Walt Disney Company, which as effectively built a market around its brand, and is known for family-friendly stuff. Even that studio, though, owns plenty of other companies that churn out the crap on the big screen (Touchstone Pictures, Hollywood Pictures, Dimension Films, Miramax Films) and TV (ABC). Aside from that though, people don’t say … “Oh my gosh, it’s another movie from Universal Pictures! Let me just throw my wallet at the screen right now!”

Based on that, these people are obviously going the wrong direction in the format war. The studios have already picked their sides in the battle, and are going to stick with HD-DVD or Blu-Ray whichever they like best. So if you wanna watch “Grandma’s Got A New Hip” in high-def, you don’t get to choose which format it’s in. The consumer is screwed, since you have to buy a DVD player that supports both, unless you want to lock yourself out from seeing movies from a certain studio.

Here’s my recommendation. Just buy non high-def DVDs until the DRM crap works itself out. In the meantime, buy a nice DVD player that does upscaling, and the picture will still look really nice on your HDTV. Works for me.

5 thoughts on “hd-dvd and blu-ray: no choices

  1. And I can’t agree more! Considering the absurd price of dual-standard readers for now, I decided to just go with a Samsung upscaling DVD player, I’m watching House on it right now and it looks fantastic, screw HD-DVD and Blu-Ray. By the way, as far as I can tell, Warner Bros is actually publishing in both standards, and with the same price for titles (The Last Samurai standard def is €12.99, HD is €24.99 for both HD-DVD and Blu Ray).

  2. I hear you. I refuse to support these companies in trying to get us to re-purchase every dvd in their own format. they try to convice us we need hi-def so they can make more money off of us. who cares about hi-def. Do you really want to see the nosehairs on Superman? I’ll stick with my 2 year old $49 dvd player that plays my free non-hi-def dvds from the library…

  3. I had not considered the upscaling option, only the dual format option. Which at I don’t really believe to be that bad a deal. Dual format players are selling for half of what a Blue-ray player sales for. I, personally, would be scared to spend money on an upscale DVD player at this point as I assume the DVD will cease to be made sooner than later.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s